201: How a Small Email List Can Be Your Most Valuable Asset
Key Takeaways
- A small, highly engaged email list can easily outperform a massive, disengaged audience when it comes to conversions and connection.
- Consistency matters more than scale, and showing up in your subscribers' inboxes every single week builds long-term trust.
- Adopting a 'serve first, sell second' copywriting approach ensures your emails are actually opened, read, and valued.
- Treating your email list as an ongoing relationship rather than a broadcast medium dramatically improves reader response rates.
- Guest copywriter Tanya Brody explains how to properly craft a strong welcome sequence to greet new subscribers from day one.
Think your email list is too small to matter?
Copywriter Tanya Brody says think again. In this episode, Tanya makes the case for why a small, engaged list can outperform a massive disengaged one, whether you're starting from zero or already have a hundred subscribers, fifty, or just three.
We cover:
- Why showing up each week beats list size
- How to start building an email list from scratch (and grow from a small one)
- The "serve first, sell second" approach to writing emails people actually want to open
- What a strong welcome sequence looks like
- How to keep your list healthy and deliverable over time
- How Tanya uses (and doesn't use) AI in her own email writing
Tanya also shares why treating your list like an ongoing relationship, not a broadcast, shapes how people respond to what you send.
Whether you're just starting your side hustle or have been putting off building an email list until you have "enough" people, this episode will change how you think about the list you already have.
Do you like what you're hearing? Consider giving it a caffeinated thumbs up. We'd really appreciate it!
Need a little (and sometimes big) push to start and stay focused to grow your side hustle? Dive into my online Masterclass: How To Turn Your Thoughts Into Wanted Things.
For the full show notes head on over to the home of Side Hustle Hero. https://www.sidehustlehero.com/201
Connect with Tanya:
Connect with Joan:
Be on the show!
Do you have a side hustle success story to tell?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is my email list too small to start making money?
Not at all! As copywriting expert Tanya Brody explains, a small and engaged list of even just a few subscribers can be more valuable than a massive, disengaged audience.
How often should I email my side hustle subscribers?
Showing up consistently each week is key to building trust and keeping your audience engaged with your brand and offers.
What is the best approach for writing marketing emails?
Focus on a 'serve first, sell second' strategy, which ensures you are providing genuine value to your readers before asking for a sale.
